|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
A REVIEW BY THE WEBMASTER SANDROCS: DONNA SUMMER: HER LIFE AND MUSIC, the
non-authorized biography by Josiah Howard, has finally been released. This
195 pages book is divided into 14 chapters, interestingly named with
Donna's song titles, that have connection with the subject within
("Fairy Tale High" showcases the Diva's childhood, "Walk
Away" centers in Donna's departure from Casablanca,
"Breakdown" spotlights Donna's bad times in the 80's, and so
on). As an appendix, there are also a text-only Discography (Singles,
Albums and some compilations) and a list of some Donna TV appearances
worldwide throughout
her career. As
for the pictures included, there are 15 black-and-white-only of them,
which are - sadly - pretty known by most of her fans (the only 2
exceptions are one of Donna and Dick Clark - from America Bandstand - and
of Donna and Paul Jabara after winning the Oscar) Since Howard said to
this site, back, in 2000 that it would contain several color pictures, my
bet is that the new publisher chose for less B&W-only pictures due to
financial reasons. According
to Howard, Donna didn't answer to his 4 requests for an interview. That's
a shame, since her unique point of view of things would help to clear some
issues that this book eventually raised. From
what I've read, I would say that Howard's book isn't offensive to Donna
(except for some deplorable comments like saying Donna looked like Sesame
Street's Big Bird on the famous picture with Mimi on the "Live &
More" album). As a whole, Howard opted for a professional, objective
writing. At
one point, the author says that, some troubles aside, "there were
some noteworthy professional - and personal - triumphs for Donna in
1978". As we all know, 1978 was the year that Donna Summer took music
business over! All her remarkable achievements in that year could never
been called as simple "noteworthy triumphs". The
bad emphasis goes on in the detailed reports of recording sessions, TV
appearances, etc. The
author completely forsakes objectivity while analyzing the albums sleeves.
Overly focused in racial subjects, Howard censures some of all-time most
acclaimed Donna Summer sleeves, including 1979's Bad Girls, On The Radio
and - most surprisingly - the superb, inventive 1989's Another Place and
Time, which features Donna in a Kabuki make-up, that perfectly fits with
the album's title. To the author, Donna was only trying to be... white! On
the positive side, DONNA SUMMER: HER LIFE AND MUSIC brings interesting and
in-depth information on Donna's early days in Europe, her relationship
with boyfriends and on her early albums as well. It's an important and
valuable item for every Donna Summer fan, since it brings relevant issues
for discussion and for some reflection on her amazing path through life.
Now, let's wait for her own upcoming book, which, as it seems, will be out
in September. A REVIEW BY SITE COLLABORATOR RAEL: While
many are still awaiting their copies of Josiah Howard's "Donna
Summer: Her Life and Her Music", many have by now also received their
copies, I received mine about a week ago. I
have to say that while we hardcore Summer fans know so much about our
beloved queen, and many things in the book would NOT be new to us, it
should be kept in mind, when read and or reviewed, that it is quite
enlightening to those not as familiar with Donna and her career. I
think Josiah did a really good job overall. Given the fact as stated on
his notes, that it is the first book in 20 years to examine her life and
career. A prior book written by Jim Haskins and J M Stifle that came out
around 1983, was quite amateur and nowhere near the obvious effort(s) made
in the writing, research and even gloss of this new book by writer and fan
of Donna's, Josiah Howard. Particularly
interesting was commentary made by Bob Esty on the recording of the
"Once Upon A Time" sessions that have not been remarked and
printed before. I love the comments about Donna's imagery on her album
covers and although I never thought of it that way, what he says about
some of the covers made me look at them and I realized "oh yeah,
that's right or she does" ..lol... particularly funny was the one
about "On The Radio". Since
some have not read it, I am trying to be discreet in not giving away
specific detail obviously. Also
left out in detail was much about Donna's relationship with Paul Jabara,
amidst many rumors we have heard that surfaced about Donna harassing
Jabara in his illness and close towards his final days, over her lawsuit
over her alleged homophobia. So
does the book paint Donna negatively or positively? I think it shows a
complex person, whose done what she needed to do for herself, out of self
survival and who may not have always thought things out in ways perhaps
she should have, or could have. Hey, she too is only human. I also think
where it seems that she may be a little difficult in approaching certain
things, be it through recordings or other outlets, Donna has shown such
herself and has made comments that add to the validity of such
difficultness. Thus
I think the book sets out to be honest and certainly not to over-glorify
Donna, yet it is written in respect to the person she seems to be, and
having met her many times, I think he has captured many accuracies, but of
course not all. She and no one else should feel ashamed of this book. In
the end she does come out triumphing, besides it is great to now to go to
a book store and bam, alphabetically there she is at last and in print. I wonder, will her forthcoming biography be an open and thoroughly honest portrait of herself? Time will tell.
on previous page: ORDINARY GIRL - THE JOURNEY (Book by Donna Summer and Marc Elliot)or RETURN TO DONNA BOOKS - Main Page
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
FOREVER DONNA website © 1999-2005 Sandro Coutinho (SandroCS) - All Rights Reserved - http://www.foreverdonna.com
For DISCLAIMERS, Click Here